These questions are the most dreaded by job candidates, with good reason.
This may be the start of the salary negotiation, if they decide to offer you a job.
From the employer’s perspective, they naturally want to pay as little as possible. Smart employers also want to pay well in comparison with their competitors so they don’t lose good employees to those competitors or other employers. But, not all employers are that smart.
The “other” salary question is the current-salary question. To understand how to answer that question, read Interview Question: What Is Your Current Salary?
Tips for Answering Compensation Questions
- Don’t “punt” in your answer to this question — that can put you at a severe disadvantage.
- Do the research to be well-prepared to answer this question.
- A “wrong” answer can result in a job offer with a salary that is too low or the end of the opportunity if you state a salary that is too high.
- Having no answer can also be the end of the opportunity. You can dodge the question for a while, as you gather information—but you likely will not be put forward for consideration unless they are sure you are “in the right range” for this job.
The bottom line is that you should have a number ready to share, based on your research and the total compensation this employer provides. If you do not answer this question, you will probably not be considered for this job.
Think About Total Compensation: Salary Is One Part
Salary is one part of total compensation, and, sometimes, other forms of compensation, like bonuses and stock or even extra vacation time and working form home, may make the total compensation acceptable even if the salary is not what you want.
You need to evaluate the total compensation package offered by any employer.
Some employers, like colleges and the US federal government, publish at least part of their salary structure on their website: the salary grades, steps within each grade, and the salary range for each grade and step. Most jobs, except for very senior executive jobs, are assigned a specific salary grade, but the complete structure may not be shared, even with current employees.
A job posting may include the salary, salary grade, and/or range. Look for this information, but don’t be surprised if you can’t find it. Few employers provide it.
In addition to the salary structure, the other parts of total compensation give you possible points to negotiate to increase the value of doing this job for this employer.
Total compensation includes the paycheck plus the benefits like:
- Signing bonus (only increasing the first year income)
- Annual, quarterly, or other bonuses
- Commissions (usually for sales jobs)
- Stock, a stock purchase plan, and/or stock options
- Annual (or more frequent) salary increases
- Vacation days
- Personal days
- Sick days
- 401K and/or pension
- Medical insurance
- Life insurance
- Dental insurance
- Vision insurance
- Working from home
- Flexible hours
- Tuition reimbursement
- Parking or public transportation reimbursement
- Company car, etc.
All of those are benefits (to you) but mostly expenses (for the employer). Prioritize these benefits for you. They can make a lower salary more acceptable, if necessary, or raise the compensation level above your expectations.
Would being able to work from home 2 or 3 days a week, more vacation, tuition reimbursement, training, a salary increase in 3 or 6 months, or a significant signing bonus be a good exchange for a higher starting salary? Which would be the most important? Which would be least?
How to Answer Salary Expectation Questions
The salary expectation question may be asked at different points in the hiring and interview process, and you can respond differently depending on the timing:
Example 1: When completing an application, either online or in person.
The application form may contain a field for “Salary Expectation.” If possible, type in a word like “negotiable” or “appropriate” or some similar answer that is relevant but is not a specific number.
Or, you may use a number from your research. If you decide to use a number, my recommendation is to choose a number from the higher end of your range rather than the lower end, but understand that being “expensive” may eliminate you from consideration, depending on the employer and their budget.
Hopefully, the number you provide (IF you provide a number) will just establish a baseline for the final negotiations later. If you receive a job offer, expect the offer to be lower than this number, in most cases.
If you don’t provide a salary number:
- You are keeping your options open. OR
- You may be eliminating yourself from consideration.
The result depends on the employer (policies and culture) and how much competition you have for this particular job.
Example 2: Postponing your answer in the interview.
A good response is to try to postpone answering until you have a better idea what the job is like and if you want it.
This should be acceptable, but, in the end, you may not be seriously considered until you provide them with a number, so best to offer an informed (researched) number rather than picking out out of the air.
⏩ Go on the offensive:
Depending on the employer, this can be very effective OR very risky, but, if asked, the answer should provide you with very useful information.
To use this question as an opportunity to collect important information about the job — like the salary grade and salary range for that grade, give this response:
Before I give you a number, I’d like to understand how you compensate employees and how this job fits into your compensation structure. I’m curious to know the salary grade for this position, the salary range and midpoint for that grade, and where that grade fits into your compensation system? That will give me a better idea of how this position fits into your structure and my career plans.
That is not a typical response, and it uses terminology that seems to indicate you understand the process. The answers to this question will provide you with very valuable information about how well-paid the job is (salary range, bottom to top, and the midpoint for the range), and where the job fits into their organization (the salary grade for this job and the other grades above and below it).
Understand that, typically, experienced employees are paid above the midpoint of their salary range. When employees greatly exceed the midpoint of a salary range (which usually increases every year as the whole salary structure increases), they usually are promoted to a different job which is usually in the next higher pay grade.
Their answer to this question will give you a very good indication if the salary for this job is a good fit for you. It also shows you where this job ranks in their organization, and how much room for growth there is for you.
⏩ Use a more conventional response:
You could go with a standard, more defensive response, and request postponing this discussion:
Before I give you a number, I’d like to understand more about company, the work environment, the requirements of the job, and other important considerations like the opportunity for growth. Then, I’ll have a better idea what an appropriate salary would be.
The request for postponement may or may not be acceptable to the interviewer. Depending on your interest in the job, you may want to give a number, or choose one of the answers below.
Example 3: Providing a salary number in the interview with this 2-part answer.
Typically, this is better time to answer this question — near the end of the interview, when you have had your questions answered and understand more about the job and the organization.
1, First, ask about total compensation if information about benefits has not been shared:
I need to understand and evaluate the total compensation package before I give you a salary number. Could you share the standard benefits you provide?
2. Then, after you understand the benefits (and how much they may cost you) use your research to give you a number for your answer to this question:
Based on my research and the information you have provided, I believe that a salary in the range of $XX,XXX to $XX,XXX with [# of weeks of] paid vacation, [other benefits important to you which have been stated as included], and your other benefits would be appropriate.
Expect that when you offer a range, they will likely pick a number at the lower end — if they do make you a job offer. So, choosing a number at the higher end of your target range may put you in the best position for future negotiations.
Salaries Can Vary Substantially Based on Job Location
The job’s location matters! If you are moving to a new state or into a large metropolitan area (or vice versa), understand that salaries change, sometimes dramatically, based on the location of the job.
Some parts of the USA are much more expensive (e.g. NYC or San Francisco) than others. Employers in the expensive areas must pay their employees more than employers in a less expensive location.
So, if you are paid $100k to do a job in NYC, expect that you will be paid less, possibly much less, for that job in a less expensive location. And if you are paid $50k for a job in a cheaper location, you could be paid more in another location, if the new location had a higher cost of living.
Hopefully, the employer you may be interviewing with includes the salary range in the job posting. Unfortunately, that practice is extremely rare (less than 10% of posted jobs have the associated salaries).
Rather than guessing at the appropriate salary, do research in advance so you understand what the probable salary range is for that job in that location. This research should be appropriate when you apply for the same job with different employers, unless you are able to determine what a specific employer pays for the job you want.
The sources and reliability of salary information are variable. Some websites offering salary information use salaries self-reported by individuals (“crowd-sourced”). Others may collect information from many employers.
⏩ Don’t stop with one source of salary data.
These sites are typically good sources of information. Use this information as part of your research, combined with the information collected from other sources:
The US Department of Labor provides useful information here: www.bls.gov. In addition, Indeed.com can give you an estimate of the salary for each job posted.
DO check multiple sources and average what you find, assuming you are making an apples-to-apples comparison. If you have colleagues or friends in this field, maybe even working for this employer, ask them generally the salary range you may expect.
DO understand that the numbers you find in your research may or may not include things like bonuses, commissions, benefits, tuition reimbursement, and all the other possible components of a total compensation package.
When you do name a number for an employer, base it on the data you found in your research. Offer a range that covers the middle to top salary you expect for the job, bearing in mind that if you receive an offer, the offer you receive will most likely be at the bottom of the range you provide.
Tell them that you are flexible, depending on the benefits provided, and the number ultimately acceptable to you depends on many things.
For more salary research tips, read How to Research and Find the Salary You Deserve.
The Bottom Line on Compensation Expectations
Your answer to this question lays the foundation for the salary negotiation process if they decide that you are their best candidate. When you start a new job, you have a “starting salary” — what you are paid at the start of your tenure in that position. The right starting salary is very important.
More About Salaries and Job Offer Negotiations:
- Guide to Salary and Compensation
- What to Say When Negotiating Your Salary (Examples)
- 5 Steps to Negotiate the Best Job Offer
- Very Important Elements of Your Compensation Negotiation
- What to Expect in a Job Offer
- Winning Negotiation Strategies for Your New Job (free ebook)
- Salary Negotiation Strategies for Stay-at-Home and Working Moms
Answering the Common Job Interview Questions:
Questions About You:
- What Is Your Greatest Achievement or Accomplishment?
- Tell Me/Us About Yourself
- Why Should We Hire You?
- What Do You Want?
- Why Do You Want THIS Job?
- What Is Your Greatest Weakness?
- What Is Your Greatest Strength?
- Why Do You Want to Leave Your Current Job?
- What Is Your Current Salary?
- What Are Your Salary Expectations?
- When Can You Start?
- Where Do You See Yourself in 5 Years?
- Smart Strategies to Answer to Behavioral Interview Questions
Handling Special Career Situations:
- Why Did You Quit Your Last Job
- After a Layoff: Why Did You Leave Your Job?
- After Being Fired: Why Did You Leave Your Job?
- Explain Your Gap in Employment
Questions About Them:
Questions for You to Ask Them:
- Do You Have Any Questions? — choose from 50+ good questions to ask them
- 5 Absolute Must-Ask Questions for the End of Your Next Interview
- The Second Interview: 5 Key Questions to Ask
- 45 Questions You Should NOT to Ask in Job Interviews
- 3 Steps to Interview Success: Build Your Interview Checklist
- The Winning Difference: Pre-Interview Preparation
Don't forget to share this article with friends!